Who Won Just Jared's Favorite Hallmark Channel Actor of 2025 Poll? See the Results!

This poll is now closed! And the winner is…

Kevin McGarry – Winner!!!

When Calls the Heart fan fave Kevin McGarry has been crowned the winner this year!

Kevin had over 123,000 votes at the end, which gave him over 42% of the total vote! Congratulations to Kevin, and thank you to all of his fans for voting!

Tyler Hynes – Second Place!!

Tyler Hynes came in second place in this poll!

Tyler had over 56,000 votes in the second place spot, and his fans voted very hard as well. Congrats to Tyler, and thank you to his fans for voting!

Niall Matter – Third Place!!

Niall Matter came in third place this year!

He had over 31,000 votes to his name.

Congrats Niall!!

Thank you to everyone who voted this year! Be sure to vote for your favorite Hallmark actress of the year here!

Head inside for the results of the poll…

ORIGINAL POST:

2025 was a massive year for the Hallmark Channel with so many amazing movies and TV shows airing on the fan fave network.

JustJared.com complied a huge list of all the most popular male Hallmark stars and we want to know which actor is your fave of them all.

Head inside to vote for your favorite of the year…

We included stars who have participated in Hallmark Channel films or TV shows recently, and those who are most popular on Just Jared. You’ll see names like Kevin McGarry, Tyler Hynes, Chris McNally, Paul Campbell, Benjamin Ayres, Andrew Walker, and more. If you think we forgot anyone very important, let us know in the comments!

Voting for this poll is unlimited, so you can vote as many times as you wish for as many of your favorite stars that you love! We’re randomizing the answer order between each refresh as well to prevent bot or automated voting.

We’ll be closing this poll on January 5, 2026 at 3 pm ET, and we will announce the winner at that time.