Waterproof Mascara Has No Chance Against These Top-Tested Eye Makeup Removers

There’s no denying the benefits of long-wear makeup, but removing those waterproof mascaras and smudge-proof liners poses a challenge. In comparison to traditional makeup removers, “an eye makeup remover is a specialized type of product used to take off makeup from around the eyes,” says Jodi LoGerfo, a Doctor of Nursing Practice at Orentreich Medical Group. “Since the area is extremely delicate, you want to use a nonirritating, gentle formula. The products should melt, dissolve, and remove makeup—including mascara, eyeshadow, and eyeliner—without causing inflammation or pain.” With so many types of eye makeup removers available (from cleansing balms and oils to wipes and water), finding the right one for your unique skin can be overwhelming. To help you select the best, we tested 29 of the most popular eye makeup removers with the help of our team of beauty testers. After ranking each on ease of application, feel, residue, and performance, we determined the best eye makeup removers fo...