'English Teacher' review: High school-set sitcom is a hilarious must-watch
If you've ever quoted comedian Brian Jordan Alvarez's web series The Gay and Wondrous Life of Caleb Gallo or sung along to his viral hit "Sitting," rejoice! Alvarez has brought his comedic sensibilities to FX, where he created and stars in the new show English Teacher.
Alvarez (who also wrote and directed several episodes) plays Evan Marquez, an English teacher at Austin's Morrison-Hensley high school. He's prone to taking stands for what he believes in, and even more prone to screwing up his moral crusades. These gaffes, combined with A-plus casting and a richly developed high school setting, make English Teacher the freshest, funniest sitcom of the year so far.
What's English Teacher about?
English Teacher gets off to a foreboding start: Evan is under investigation after a homophobic parent complained about him kissing his boyfriend Malcolm (Jordan Firstman) — now ex — in front of students. That an external force is trying to govern Evan's teaching becomes a common thread throughout English Teacher, as the show addresses several serious real-world issues over the course of its season, including gun safety in schools and LGBTQ rights.
Don't let the heaviness of these topics fool you, though. English Teacher is no after-school special. Instead, the series highlights not only the ridiculousness of the problems Evan faces, but also the ridiculousness of Evan's own reactions, each of which lead to some comedically misguided escalations. An attempt to cancel a performance where football players dress up as cheerleaders leads Evan to hold a drag seminar taught by local drag queen Shazam (played by drag superstar Trixie Mattel). The rise of a school gun safety club prompts Evan to assign the world's most misguided essay on Crime and Punishment.
Nothing here goes according to plan, nor does English Teacher ever take the predictable route. Look no further than a possible romance with substitute teacher Harry (Langston Kerman), which does not play out the way audiences (or Evan himself) might think. While that storyline fades away rather abruptly in the latter half of the six English Teacher episodes sent to critics for screening, it's just one example of how the series prefers to chart its own path.
English Teacher has a perfect cast.
English Teacher, like The Gay and Wondrous Life of Caleb Gallo, sets a particular tone and pace right off the bat. There's a shorthand intimacy between these characters who have known each other for years. They talk super quickly, even over each other, enveloping us in their world with just a few lines. Quick asides, such as an "Oh, I love this song!" delivered mid-principled tirade, often tell us all we need to know about someone.
As the show's creator, Alvarez naturally excels at mastering this tone, delivering an assured lead performance that makes Evan's frustrations with and passion for teaching both believable and hilarious. His fellow castmates match him every step of the way. Stephanie Koenig shines as Evan's best friend and fellow teacher Gwen; you can tell she and Alvarez are longtime collaborators from the sheer ease and specificity of their comedic chemistry. Other standouts include Sean Patton as often inappropriate (yet surprisingly insightful) gym teacher Markie, and Enrico Colantoni as frazzled Principal Grant, who all but runs the other way when he sees Evan coming.
The charm of English Teacher's cast and characters extend to Morrison-Hensley's students, played by a large ensemble of young actors including Aliyah Bah (aka Aliyah's Interlude), Romy Mars, Ben Bondurant, and Ivy Wolk. While Morrison-Hensley's faculty may not always understand their students — "They're not into being woke anymore," Evan laments — English Teacher takes great pains to do so, building out the students beyond simple high school archetypes. Their screen time may be limited, but these students still feel like they have rich inner lives. In some cases, they could even be smarter and more well-adjusted than the adults they're meant to be learning from.
Having such a detailed ensemble grounds English Teacher in the reality of high school, even if its plotlines are mostly heightened for comedy's sake. And just like its school-set compatriot Abbott Elementary, English Teacher still has quite a bit to say about the good public school teachers do, in spite several encroaching problems that may hinder them. That messaging, and the show's breakneck pacing and killer dialogue, send English Teacher and Alvarez rocketing to the top of the sitcom class.