What We Know About the Trump Campaign’s Arlington National Cemetery Incident
Donald Trump visited Arlington National Cemetery on Monday to commemorate 13 American servicemembers killed in Afghanistan three years ago. But reporting soon emerged about an altercation between his campaign staff and a cemetery official over photography in a restricted section, sparking a backlash that has only grown stronger. Although Trump’s team has cited the support of the Gold Star family members accompanying him on the visit, critics allege that the Republican candidate has run afoul of federal law that forbids campaign activity at the site. Here, what we know so far.
What happened at Arlington National Cemetery?
Trump was at the cemetery to take part in a ceremony honoring the 13 U.S. servicemembers who were killed in a suicide bombing at Abbey Gate during the chaotic military withdrawal from Afghanistan. During his visit, he laid wreaths at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier and stopped by the burial sites of several servicemembers alongside their relatives and loved ones.
But NPR reported that an altercation occurred between Trump campaign staff and an Arlington employee. It took place as members of Trump’s team attempted to take photographs and record videos in Section 60, an area of the cemetery largely reserved for members of the military who died while serving in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. A source told NPR that a cemetery employee tried to prevent those staffers from entering that section but that they then “verbally abused and pushed the official aside.”
Arlington National Cemetery confirmed in a statement to NPR that the incident took place and that a report had been filed, indicating that the campaign’s actions might have been illegal. “Federal law prohibits political campaign or election-related activities within Army National Military Cemeteries, to include photographers, content creators or any other persons attending for purposes, or in direct support of a partisan political candidate’s campaign,” the statement said. “Arlington National Cemetery reinforced and widely shared this law and its prohibitions with all participants.”
On Wednesday, the Associated Press reported that Trump’s team had been warned about not taking photographs or videos at Section 60 prior to its arrival at Arlington, citing a defense official.
An Army spokesman issued a statement on Thursday, again confirming the incident without mentioning Trump or his campaign directly. “An ANC employee who attempted to ensure adherence to these rules was abruptly pushed aside. Consistent with the decorum expected at ANC, this employee acted with professionalism and avoided further disruption,” the statement read. The spokesman confirmed that a report was made to the police but that the employee opted against pressing charges. The employee reportedly feared retaliation from Trump’s supporters if she pursued charges, military officials told the New York Times.
Before the cemetery visit, Trump was already under increased scrutiny for his rhetoric about the military, following recent comments in which he said the Presidential Medal of Freedom, a civilian honor, was better than receiving the Medal of Honor, the nation’s highest military award. In 2020, The Atlantic published a story alleging that then-President Trump had referred to American WWI veterans buried in the Aisne-Marne American Cemetery near Paris as “losers” and “suckers” in 2018 when explaining his reasoning for canceling a trip to the site, citing sources familiar with the conversation.
What has the Trump campaign’s response been?
Trump’s campaign immediately took a defensive posture after the incident was reported, largely blaming the individual cemetery official. In a statement to NPR, which first broke the story, Trump spokesman Steven Cheung denied that a physical altercation occurred and said Trump’s team was prepared to release its own footage to combat the “defamatory claims.”
“The fact is that a private photographer was permitted on the premises and for whatever reason an unnamed individual, clearly suffering from a mental health episode, decided to physically block members of President Trump’s team during a very solemn ceremony,” he said.
The campaign has also circulated a statement signed by relatives of two of the fallen servicemembers, Sergeant Darin Taylor Hoover and Sergeant Nicole Gee, saying they gave permission for Trump’s official photographer and videographer to attend the ceremony and that the Republican candidate and his team “conducted themselves with nothing but the utmost respect and dignity.”
Trump’s running mate, J.D. Vance, dismissed the controversy as a media-led creation during a Wednesday campaign stop and took a shot at Vice-President Kamala Harris, blaming her for the 2021 attack that occurred under the Biden administration. “Three years ago, 13 brave, innocent Americans died, and they died because Kamala Harris refused to do her job, and there hasn’t been a single investigation or a single firing,” he said.
Vance then accused Harris of trying to criticize Trump for the Arlington visit, though the vice-president herself had yet to comment publicly on the incident at that time. “And she wants to yell at Donald Trump because he showed up? She can — she can go to hell,” he said.
.@JDVance: "Kamala Harris is so asleep at the wheel that she won't even do an investigation into what happened and she wants to give Donald Trump because he showed up, she can go to hell!" pic.twitter.com/hoUO0DRhQm
— CSPAN (@cspan) August 28, 2024
Did Trump’s visit to Section 60 violate federal law?
Arlington National Cemetery is a frequent location for official visits by American leaders with presidents often marking Memorial Day and Veterans Day with remarks and a wreath-laying ceremony at the historic site. Generally, the cemetery allows photography by members of the public within its grounds with more specific rules for the media. But Trump’s visit might be in conflict with 32 CFR 553, a federal regulation that states, “Memorial services and ceremonies at Army National Military Cemeteries will not include partisan political activities.”
The campaign’s use of the footage taken on Monday so far appears to be political in nature. Dan Scavino Jr., a senior campaign adviser whose social-media feeds largely consist of ads and clips of campaign rallies, shared a video of Trump at the grave of one servicemember with members of their family.
— Dan Scavino Jr.???????????? (@DanScavino) August 26, 2024
Trump later shared a video on TikTok featuring footage taken from his Arlington visit, including him visiting graves located in Section 60 with Gold Star family members. The accompanying audio left no doubt that the video was intended as a political message. It featured a voice-over of Trump condemning the Biden administration for its handling of the Afghanistan withdrawal: “We didn’t lose one person in 18 months and then they took over that disaster, the leaving of Afghanistan.”
Although the legal questions surrounding the incident remain open, Trump’s visit has upset at least one Gold Star family. The Times reported that relatives of Master Sergeant Andrew Marckesano have expressed concerns that Trump filmed at his grave site without permission. Marckesano’s headstone can be seen in videos of Trump laying flowers in Section 60 next to the grave of Sergeant Hoover, whose family accompanied the former president to the site.
In a statement to the Times, Marckesano’s sister, Michele, said that their family supports Hoover’s family and others in their quest for more information surrounding the Afghanistan bombing. “However, according to our conversation with Arlington National Cemetery, the Trump campaign staffers did not adhere to the rules that were set in place for this visit to Staff Sergeant Hoover’s gravesite in Section 60, which lays directly next to my brother’s grave,” she said.