Watch the moment Love Island’s Casey finally names villa rival – weeks after All Star revealed secret feud
LOVE Island’s Casey O’Gorman has finally confirmed who his villa rival is.
The 28-year-old, who took part in the All Stars spin-off earlier this year, confessed that he didn’t “see eye to eye” with Toby Aromolaran.
During his recent appearance on the Not My Bagg podcast with Callum Jones, they were asked who they “couldn’t stand” in the villa.
Casey said: “I didn’t see eye to eye with Toby.
He added: “He was probably my least close boy.”
The hunk didn’t elaborate much more on why during the episode.
It comes just weeks after their secret feud was exposed when the footballer took a swipe at Casey.
Toby and co-star Chris Taylor spoke about the moment everyone picked Chris and Joanna Chimonides for the majority of the answers during the Couple Goals game.
Recalling what he discussed with his partner Georgia Steel, Toby said on his Fancy A Chat podcast: “Look, I love everyone… not everyone.
“But love people around this fire pit, we have to play this game properly. We can’t cop out.
“Then it got to like the most one-sided couple and I was thinking and looking around… Chris and Joanna.”
This left many people wondering who he meant when he said “not everyone”.
Some Love Island fans took to Reddit to discuss – and Casey’s name came up.
One fan pointed out on Reddit: “who do we think is the not everyone?! if i had to guess, i would think maybe casey. i feel like the only boys casey truly got along with were tom, callum, and josh. he seems like the kind of guy who just cannot fake his feelings, either in friendships or romantically.”
Another replied: “Sorry just to add to this, I think it really might be Casey because at times Casey seemed hostile towards Toby. Like all during PDA night or any other time Toby kinda stood up for GS when she was catching heat, Casey was always seen making faces/comments or nudging Tom/Callum.”
“Casey for sure,” a third chimed in.
A fourth wrote: “I think it’s Casey as well.”
Casey failed to find love on the show, but Toby left the villa hand in hand with Georgia Steel.
However the pair split shortly after returning to the UK.
Casey gave his opinion on their break-up after the news broke.
He told us: “I’m not sure if I saw it lasting, in the villa it’s just so different and I guess they did it before on The Games and that didn’t work out and they’ve given it another go and that’s not worked out.
“I think you’re sceptical of everyone when you come out – because everyone seems so strong in there and as soon as you get out, they’re gone, people split up very quickly.
“I don’t really know Toby and Georgia that well, I wasn’t very close to them in the villa. So I don’t know how strong they were as a couple.”
Love Island winners - where they are now
Every year Love Island opens its doors to more sexy Islanders who are hoping for a holiday romance that could turn into more.
Here we take you though all of the Love Island winners so far and what their relationship statuses are now:
2024 – The first ever All stars spin off show was won by Molly Smith and Tom Clare. STATUS: Still together.
2023 – Jess Harding and Sammy Root took home the 50K, and won the summer 2023 Love Island. STATUS: Broken up.
2023 – The first series of 2023 saw Sanam Harrinanan and Kai Fagan crowned Love Island winners in South Africa. STATUS: Still together.
2022 – Davide Sanclimenti and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu’s time in the villa was anything but a smooth ride, but they managed to win the public’s hearts – and the ITV2 reality show. STATUS: Broken up.
2021 – Liam Reardon and Millie Court were announced winners of Love Island 2021. STATUS: Still together.
2020 – The first ever winter Love Island saw Paige Turley and Finn Tapp crowned winners after falling in love on the show. STATUS: Broken up.
2019 – Series 5 saw Tommy Fury and Molly-Mae Hague runners up to winners Greg O’Shea and Amber Gill, who met in the last few days of the series. STATUS: Broken up.
2018 – It wasn’t surprising fan favourites Jack Fincham and Dani Dyer won the show, as they were strong throughout. But sadly things didn’t last. STATUS: Broken up.
2017 – Kem Cetinay and Amber Davies had lots of ups and downs in the villa but went on to win the show. STATUS: Broken up.
2016 – Nathan Massey and Cara De La Hoyde were together form the start of the series, and since they won show have two kids and are married. STATUS: Still together.
2015 – Despite poor Jess Hayes being Max Morley’s second choice on the show, they did win – but they didn’t last as a couple. STATUS: Broken up.