The 12 best organic dog treats of 2024

When you buy through our links, Business Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Organic food isn't just for people. In recent years, pet food companies have been rolling out organic grub, including some of the best organic dog treats. That may be in response to consumer demand, especially as people become more environmentally conscious, something a report from Future Markets Insights notes.

Although there are fewer organic dog treats than conventional ones, the options are growing. To help you narrow down the best organic dog treats, I looked at dozens of brands and flavors and made my picks based on the criteria veterinarians shared. One of our top picks, Callie's Kitchen Organic Chicken with Pumpkin Recipe, is a soft and chewy treat that's both made in the US and USDA-certified organic.

People may assume that organic dog foods and treats have a nutritional edge over their conventional counterparts, but there isn't definitive evidence at this time. "Organic foods have been shown to have small increases in nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids and antioxidants when compared with their non-organic counterparts," says Dr. Kasey Aona, medical director and owner of GoodVets in Columbus, Ohio. "That said, though, there haven't been any studies to prove the nutritional benefits of feeding organic treats over non-organic ones in dogs." 

Read more about how Insider Reviews tests and researches pet products.

Highlights for the best organic dog treats

Best overall: Callie's Kitchen Organic Chicken with Pumpkin Recipe - See at Chewy

Best for training: Wet Noses Sweet Potato Little Stars Dog Treats - See at Chewy

Best for small dogs: V-Dog Peanut Butter Wiggle Biscuits - See at Chewy

Best for large dogs: Fetch Fries Organic Chicken and Sweet Potato Recipe - See at Chewy

Best for puppies: Riley's Organic Sweet Potato Small Biscuits - See at Chewy

Best for senior dogs: Lord Jameson Golden Health Organic Dog Treats - See at Chewy

Best overall

Certified organic dog treats have a USDA Organic Seal printed on their package. The seal signifies that at least 95% of the ingredients are certified organic; the remaining 5% have been organically produced, though some exceptions exist. 

Our top picks carry the USDA Organic Seal, and their size is appropriate for most dogs. Like our picks for the best dog treats, they come in flavors most pups like, including sweet potato, chicken, and pumpkin. In addition, we selected treats that consist mainly of whole foods, based on the recommendation of Dr. Antonio DeMarco, chief medical and mentorship officer at GoodVets in Lee's Summit, Missouri. "Although fresh vegetables and fruits are my first choice, there are some good options in local pet stores," he says.

Best for training

Training treats are smaller, making them easier to stuff into pockets and training pouches. But while it's great to provide positive reinforcement with treats, calories can add up fast. "Training treats can look innocent because they're typically small, which makes it easy to overdo them," says Bullen. 

Another rule of thumb when choosing a training treat is to make sure it's something the dog really loves. "Having a high-value treat that a pet is truly excited about is helpful, although that can vary from pet to pet," says Dr. Nancy Welborn, associate professor and service chief of community practice at the Louisiana State University School of Veterinary Medicine. 

Best for small dogs

Small dogs have smaller mouths than larger dogs, so buying them appropriately sized treats makes sense. "Smaller dogs who eat treats made for larger dogs have the potential to choke on that treat," says Kara Burns, a licensed veterinary technician specializing in nutrition and editor-in-chief of Today's Veterinary Nurse.  

Calories are another concern. Too many calories can lead to excess weight, which can cause several health issues ranging from joint problems to diabetes. As of 2018, 56% of dogs were overweight or obese, according to a clinical survey conducted by the Association for Pet Obesity Prevention. No matter a dog's size, treats should account for no more than 10% their total caloric intake. If possible, Aona recommends keeping it closer to 5%. 

Best for large dogs

Even with large dogs, you still need to keep an eye on calories when it comes to treats. The same guidelines for small dogs apply: Treats should compose no more than 10% of total caloric intake. There's a little more leeway when it comes to the size of the treat, though this varies with each dog. For this reason, it's best to give larger treats sparingly.

Suppose your dog inhales treats like a vacuum cleaner. In that case, it's possible they could aspirate on super small treats if you're not monitoring them, says Dr. Lindsey E. Bullen, a board-certified veterinary nutritionist with Friendship Hospital for Animals in Washington, DC. Other large dogs, however, might eat small pieces of food in a slow and controlled manner. Ultimately, it comes down to knowing how your dog eats while also considering their texture and flavor preferences.

Best for puppies

Whether you're showing your puppy some love or doing some training, keep any treats you give puppies small in size and calories. Check the fronts of packages, which often specify what life stage they're for, or opt for training treats. Burns says that larger-sized treats could pose a choking hazard.

Training treats are also great to add to your pantry. "They're small in size, making them a great option to reinforce positive behaviors without worrying too much about overfeeding," says DeMarco. The treats should also be soft enough to break them apart with your fingers. "If they're too hard, they could damage fragile puppy teeth," he adds.

Best for senior dogs

It's tempting to treat senior dogs with anything they want. They've earned it, right? Yet consider treats with omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil or a joint health supplement, many of which come in a soft-chew version. "Omega-3 fatty acids can reduce inflammation related to arthritis and promote brain and skin health," says DeMarco. It's important to note that not all supplements are created equal. We've written about the best fish oils for dogs and the best joint supplements for dogs, but ultimately, your veterinarian can tell you what's best for your dog. 

And, of course, don't forget that you can support your dog's cognitive function and provide a source of enrichment for meals and treats by using a puzzle feeder, says DeMarco. Just make sure you start slowly by offering a relatively easy puzzle feeder at first so your dog doesn't get frustrated. 

What to look for in organic dog treats

Here are some points to keep in mind when shopping for the best organic dog treats.

USDA Organic Seal: Look for the seal on the treat's packaging. These treats are subject to the same standards as the certified organic food we humans eat. This means that if the treat's label carries a USDA Organic seal, the food must contain at least 95% organic ingredients. By extension, organic ingredients are GMO-free and have not been treated with chemical pesticides or synthetic fertilizers. Any of the treat's non-organic ingredients (5% or less) must be present on the National List of Allowed Substances, which requires all ingredients to be generally recognized as safe by the FDA.

Ingredient and calorie information: A treat's packaging should include the ingredients and calories per treat. If this information isn't on the label, it should be easy to find on the brand's website.

Your dog's weight: Assess your dog's weight to figure out if your dog can have extra calories in a day, but do not exceed 5% to 10% calories from treats. The Pet Nutrition Alliance Calorie Calculator for Dogs is an excellent resource for determining the number of calories your dog should consume. You can also check with your veterinarian if you're unsure. If a treat's calories are on the higher end, consider whether you can break it apart into smaller portions. Some brands design treats that are easy to break apart.

Flavor and texture: Consider the treat's flavor and whether your dog enjoys it. Many dogs love peanut butter, sweet potato, pumpkin, and chicken. Soft treats are typically easier to break apart, which may be helpful for training or cutting down on calories. Dogs with dental problems may struggle with crunchy treats. However, dogs who gobble up treats may do better with crunchy biscuits that take time to chew.

Toxic ingredients: Make sure the treat doesn't contain ingredients that are harmful to dogs. These include ingredients like garlic and onion powder. Consult your veterinarian if you are unsure about specific ingredients. 

Food sensitivities and allergies: If your dog has allergies, scan the ingredient list to make sure it's safe for your dog.

Product recalls: Make sure the brand hasn't made frequent or serious recalls. You can find this information on the US Food and Drug Administration(FDA) Recalls, Market Withdrawals, and Safety Alerts website.

Misleading claims: Similar to choosing the best dog food for your pup, be cautious if a brand claims its treats will cure ailments. "I counsel clients to look at the claims, and if they're too good to be true — like curing a disease state — it's probably not the best choice," says Bullen. And while terms like "natural," "real," "holistic," and "premium" may sound appealing, they are common marketing buzzwords that do not signify a treat's quality or nutritional value. We didn't exclude these treats from our guide, but these terms didn't influence our selections.

How we selected the best organic dog treats

I searched for treats that met USDA Organic standards. I also considered the ingredients in the treat, opting for treats with fewer ingredients overall and more ingredients from whole foods. Finally, I consulted with veterinary experts to discuss the potential benefits of organic treats and what dog guardians should look for when choosing them. We also relied on customer reviews and the preferences of our tasters, an 8-year-old golden retriever/lab mix and 8-month-old golden retriever puppy. 

Organic dog treats FAQs

Are organic treats good for dogs? 

The data is inconclusive at this point. Yet there's nothing wrong with giving your dog organic treats, especially if eating organic aligns with your personal beliefs. Just know that you may be paying more for organic versus non-organic treats, and you'll have to weigh whether the difference is worth it. "It's hard to say this increase in cost is justified without a demonstrated benefit," says Aona. "However, for pet parents who feel strongly about feeding organic and aren't deterred by the price, organic treats are not a wrong choice." 

What is the healthiest treat for a dog? 

Fruits and vegetables are often the healthiest treats, Aona says. You can also make your vegetable chews in a dehydrator or bake your own dog biscuits. Just avoid added sugars and artificial sweeteners, like xylitol, which are toxic to dogs. If your dog is a chewer, Aona recommends filling rubber toys with a thin layer of peanut butter, as you don't run the risk of cracking teeth as you might with hard bones and antlers. Keep treats to around 10% of your dog's diet, although Aona advises pet parents to get that number closer to 5%. If, however, your dog is already overweight or obese, treats should be restricted or avoided.  

What dog treats are organic? 

The USDA hasn't yet set standards for organic pet foods, according to The Ohio State University. Look for the USDA Organic Seal on the label, which means the treats follow the standards for organic human food and their ingredients consist of at least 95% organic ingredients by weight. You might also see "made with organic," which means at least 70% of the treat's ingredients are organic. 

What are the safest treats for dogs? 

Whether organic or not, the safest treats have limited ingredients with names you can pronounce, Aona says. "When in doubt, reach for raw vegetables and fruits like carrots and green beans," she says. Just remember that some foods like onion, garlic, and grapes can be toxic to dogs. Find a list of human foods to avoid at the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.